How do you identify a cash-generating unit under IAS 36, and what are the practical criteria for grouping assets?

Question

AcadiFi · Accepted Answer

The cash-generating unit (CGU) is a foundational concept in IAS 36 impairment testing, and correctly identifying CGUs determines how impairment losses are measured and allocated.

**Definition**

A CGU is the **smallest identifiable group of assets** that generates cash inflows that are **largely independent** of the cash inflows from other assets or groups of assets. The focus is on cash **inflows**, not outflows.

**Practical Identification Criteria**

IAS 36 provides guidance through several factors:

**Worked Example — Haverford Hospitality Group:**

Haverford operates three hotel properties: a downtown business hotel, a resort hotel 50 miles away, and a conference center attached to the downtown hotel. Management must determine CGU boundaries for impairment testing.

| Factor | Downtown Hotel + Conference Center | Resort Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Independent revenue streams? | Conference center depends on hotel guests (70% overlap) | Fully independent clientele |
| Separate management reporting? | Combined P&L | Separate P&L |
| Could be sold independently? | Conference center has no standalone market | Yes |
| Independent pricing decisions? | Bundled packages | Own pricing |
| **CGU classification** | **One CGU** | **Separate CGU** |

The conference center cannot be a standalone CGU because its cash inflows are not largely independent of the downtown hotel.

**Key Identification Factors:**

1. **Revenue independence** — Does the asset group generate revenue on its own, or does it depend on other assets?
2. **Management monitoring** — How does management track performance? Internal reporting lines often indicate CGU boundaries.
3. **Market independence** — Could the asset group be sold as a going concern?
4. **Geographic or product-line segmentation** — Separate markets often indicate separate CGUs.
5. **Regulatory environment** — Different regulatory zones may force separate identification.

**Common Exam Pitfalls:**

- A single factory producing goods for external sale is typically **one CGU**, even if it has multiple production lines.
- A vertically integrated operation where one division sells exclusively to another cannot treat that division as a separate CGU (inflows are not independent).
- Corporate headquarters and shared assets are **not** CGUs themselves — they are allocated to other CGUs for testing.

**Why It Matters for Impairment:**

If CGUs are defined too broadly, impairment losses can be masked by profitable segments within the unit. If defined too narrowly, entities may recognize impairment that would disappear at a higher level. Examiners test whether candidates can apply judgment to these boundary decisions.

Review our CFA Level II FRA materials for more IAS 36 practice problems.

How do you identify a cash-generating unit under IAS 36, and what are the practical criteria for grouping assets?

Master Level II with our CFA Course

Related Questions

Practice Questions