How do you value a tracking stock and what governance concerns should analysts consider?

Question

AcadiFi · Accepted Answer

A tracking stock is a special class of equity issued by a parent company whose price is intended to track the financial performance of a specific division or subsidiary, without legally separating that division.

**Valuation Approach:**

Since the tracked division typically does not have a standalone balance sheet, analysts must construct a pro forma financial statement:

1. **Revenue and EBITDA**: Usually reported separately by the parent in segment disclosures
2. **Capital allocation**: Determine what share of corporate overhead and capital expenditure is attributable to the division
3. **Tax rate**: Apply the parent's effective tax rate unless the division operates in different jurisdictions
4. **Comparable valuation**: Use EV/EBITDA or P/E multiples from pure-play comparables

**Example — Langford Corp Tracking Stock:**
Langford Corp issues LANG.A (tracking its streaming division) and LANG.B (tracking its cable division).

| Metric | Streaming Division |
|---|---|
| Revenue | $3.2 billion |
| EBITDA | $640 million |
| Allocated corporate overhead | $120 million |
| Adjusted EBITDA | $520 million |
| Pure-play streaming comp EV/EBITDA | 14x |
| **Implied EV** | **$7.28 billion** |

**Governance Concerns:**

1. **No legal separation**: Tracking stock holders have no direct claim on the division's assets. If the parent goes bankrupt, tracking stock holders are general creditors of the parent, not the division.

2. **Board conflict of interest**: The same board oversees both classes. Decisions about capital allocation, intercompany pricing, and resource sharing may disadvantage one class.

3. **Dividend discretion**: The parent determines dividend payments for the tracking stock. It could redirect cash from the profitable division to subsidize a struggling one.

4. **Conversion risk**: The parent can unilaterally convert the tracking stock into regular shares at terms potentially unfavorable to tracking stock holders.

5. **Tax complications**: Since there's no legal separation, tracking stock holders cannot claim losses specific to the division.

**CFA Exam Focus:** Distinguish between tracking stocks (no legal separation, governance risk) and spin-offs (legal separation, cleaner valuation). Know that tracking stocks typically trade at a discount to pure-play comparables.

Join our CFA equity community for more corporate structure discussions.

How do you value a tracking stock and what governance concerns should analysts consider?

Master Level II with our CFA Course

Related Questions

Practice Questions