When and why are stock options excluded from diluted EPS as anti-dilutive, and how do you test for anti-dilution?

Question

AcadiFi · Accepted Answer

Anti-dilutive securities are excluded from diluted EPS because including them would increase EPS or reduce the loss per share, which would be misleading. The anti-dilution test depends on both the security type and whether the company reports net income or a net loss.

**Fundamental Rule:**

A potentially dilutive security is anti-dilutive if its inclusion would **increase** EPS (or reduce loss per share). Such securities must be excluded from the diluted EPS calculation.

**Stock Options — The Exercise Price Test:**

Options are anti-dilutive when the exercise price exceeds the average market price (out-of-the-money). Under the treasury stock method, out-of-the-money options would result in the company buying back MORE shares than it issues, which would reduce the denominator and increase EPS.

**Worked Example:**

Pinnacle Dynamics has the following:

| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Net income | $12.4M |
| Basic shares outstanding | 5,000,000 |
| Option A: 200,000 options, exercise price $30 | Avg market price: $45 |
| Option B: 150,000 options, exercise price $50 | Avg market price: $45 |

*Option A (in-the-money, $30 < $45) — Dilutive:*
- Proceeds: 200,000 x $30 = $6,000,000
- Shares repurchased: $6,000,000 / $45 = 133,333
- Net new shares: 200,000 - 133,333 = **66,667 incremental shares**
- These increase the denominator, reducing EPS — **dilutive, include**

*Option B (out-of-the-money, $50 > $45) — Anti-dilutive:*
- Proceeds: 150,000 x $50 = $7,500,000
- Shares repurchased: $7,500,000 / $45 = 166,667
- Net new shares: 150,000 - 166,667 = **-16,667 shares**
- These would decrease the denominator, increasing EPS — **anti-dilutive, exclude**

**The Net Loss Exception:**

When a company reports a net loss, ALL potentially dilutive securities become anti-dilutive. This is because adding shares to the denominator would reduce the loss per share, making the financial performance appear better than it actually is. In a loss year, diluted EPS equals basic EPS.

**Ordering Rule:**

When multiple dilutive securities exist, they must be tested individually in order from most dilutive to least dilutive. If adding a security causes cumulative diluted EPS to exceed the previous step, that security (and all remaining) are anti-dilutive and excluded.

**Key Exam Traps:**
- Net loss = always report basic EPS as diluted EPS
- Options with exercise price equal to market price produce zero incremental shares (neutral, typically excluded)
- Convertible bonds that are anti-dilutive individually may still need to be tested in the ordering sequence

Sharpen your EPS skills in our CFA FRA question bank.

When and why are stock options excluded from diluted EPS as anti-dilutive, and how do you test for anti-dilution?

Master Level I with our CFA Course

Related Questions

Practice Questions