Why does the weighted average cost per unit differ between periodic and perpetual inventory systems?
I got a practice problem wrong because I used the same average cost for both systems. The answer key shows different COGS figures. How can the same method produce different results just because of when you compute the average?
Under the weighted average cost method, the average cost per unit depends on when you calculate it. In a periodic system, you compute one average at the end of the period using all purchases. In a perpetual system, you recalculate the average after every purchase, and each sale uses the average at that moment.
Periodic Weighted Average You wait until period-end, pool all units available (beginning inventory + all purchases), and divide total cost by total units. This single average is applied to all units sold and units remaining.
Perpetual Moving Average After each purchase, you recalculate the average cost of units on hand. When a sale occurs, COGS is based on the current moving average.
Example: Trident Supplies has the following transactions in March:
| Date | Transaction | Units | Cost/Unit | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 1 | Beginning inventory | 200 | $40 | $8,000 |
| Mar 10 | Purchase | 300 | $44 | $13,200 |
| Mar 18 | Sale | 250 | -- | -- |
| Mar 25 | Purchase | 150 | $48 | $7,200 |
Periodic Method: Total units available = 200 + 300 + 150 = 650 Total cost = 13,200 + 28,400 Average cost = 43.69 per unit** COGS for 250 units = 250 x 10,923**
Perpetual Method: After Mar 10 purchase: (200 x 44) / 500 = 42.40** Mar 18 sale of 250 units: COGS = 250 x 10,600** Remaining: 250 units at 10,600 After Mar 25 purchase: (48) / 400 = 44.50**
Loading diagram...
Why the Difference? Periodic includes the Mar 25 purchase ($48/unit) in the average that applies to the Mar 18 sale, even though that purchase had not yet occurred. Perpetual only uses costs available at the time of each sale.
COGS Difference: 10,600 = $323
In a rising-cost environment, periodic weighted average typically produces higher COGS than perpetual because the later, higher-cost purchases are averaged into sales that occurred earlier.
Exam Tip: If a question specifies "periodic" or "perpetual," the calculation method changes. Always check which system applies before computing.
Practice more inventory cost flow problems in our CFA Level I question bank.
Master Level I with our CFA Course
107 lessons · 200+ hours· Expert instruction
Related Questions
Why does an early retirement provision lower risk tolerance but high turnover does not — both reduce liabilities, right?
Why does it matter if the pension fund is invested in stocks similar to the sponsor's business?
What is the rule about active vs retired lives and pension plan duration?
Why does the textbook recommend 100% equities for a young employee? That sounds extremely aggressive.
I run my own startup. My income is volatile and tied to my industry. Should I hold ZERO equities in my financial accounts?
Join the Discussion
Ask questions and get expert answers.